Winter Manure Application Tips from the Experts

By Chryseis Modderman, Extension Educator

January 2020

Manure application on snowHere we go again, another winter where manure applications might be unavoidable. Here in Minnesota, winter application is not banned for all operations, and exceedingly wet falls have made it a necessary evil for some producers.

The problem is a struggle between minimizing runoff and logistics. If time runs out for applications, storage overflow can become a problem in the winter. Unfortunately, cows aren’t going to stop crapping, so that manure has to go somewhere.

This was the focus of a discussion activity I had with a group of commercial manure haulers: what do you do when faced with dwindling storage space, but fields are too wet or frozen/snow-covered? The goal was for participants, and myself, to learn from each other, and to plumb the deep well of knowledge of applicators who have seen it all. Here is what they came up with:

Tips from Commercial Manure Applicators

  • In a wet fall, saturated fields are a no-go, especially when using a large liquid tanker. Runoff risk is high, and future compaction issues make it not worthwhile (not to mention the likelihood of getting stuck). When asked about applying in saturated soils, top responses from applicators were: “pray that it stops raining” and “wait it out.”
  • Well, what if you get pinched between a rock and a hard place and it just won’t stop raining, and ground-freeze or substantial snowfall has occurred? Then it is time to assess storage. Specifically, how much manure needs to be moved or applied to avoid storage overflows before spring applications can be made?
  • First and foremost, if liquid storage is at risk of overflowing, contact the MPCA or your County Feedlot Officer so they are aware, on the same page, and can help you come up with solutions.
  • Storage overflow is considered a manure spill, and the appropriate response must be made, including notifying the MN Duty Officer at 1-800-422-0798.
  • Solid manure is relatively easier than liquid to manage in adverse conditions because temporary stockpiles can be created to stall application. Make sure these temporary stockpiles are in compliance with local rules.
  • Whether under wet or winter conditions, if storage is about to be tapped out, manure should be transferred to other storage facilities – if any have room – or land-applied.
  • In general, when conditions are dire, pollutant discharge risk is lower for land applications than a storage breach when application sites are carefully chosen. With land applications, you must do all you reasonably can do to avoid pollution from contaminated runoff.
  • Choosing the right application site to minimize runoff is crucial. Choose the flattest, driest fields possible. Applying to select portions of fields may be the best option. Fields with more residue and furrows will hold manure better than bare fields.
  • If possible, incorporate or inject the manure into the soil to lower runoff risk.
  • Follow setback requirements. Under winter conditions, the required setback from all sensitive features (lakes, streams, wetlands, drainage ditches, tile inlets, etc.) is 300 feet. It is also best practice to adopt this setback in wet conditions.
  • Make sure you are applying appropriate nutrient rates and following the recently updated UMN guidelines. If applying on top of snow or frozen soil, reduced application rates may be more appropriate.
  • Do not apply when a large rain or snowmelt event is expected in the next 24-48 hours. A great free online tool to help you determine when runoff is expected is the Minnesota Runoff Risk Advisory Forecast. It shows the runoff risk for the present and future days. You can even sign up for text or email alerts that tell you when runoff risk is high.
  • Remember, local rules may be more stringent than state rules, so make sure to know your county requirements before application.
  • You may have additional restrictions depending on your operation’s permit. If you have an NPDES or SDS permit, you may not be allowed to apply liquid manure after November 30 unless your situation is deemed an emergency according to the conditions of the permit. In this situation, you must notify the MN Duty Officer of your emergency application of liquid manure from a NPDES or SDS permitted site. With these permits, solid manure applications after November 30 may occur under certain restrictions.
  • As always, safety should not be neglected. Be mindful of dangerous gases, equipment hazards, and fatigue to keep you, your loved ones, and your operation safe and thriving.

© 2020 Regents of the University of Minnesota.  All rights reserved. University of Minnesota Extension is an equal opportunity educator and employer.  In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, this material is available in alternative formats upon request. Direct requests to 612-624-1222.